Mental Health

I'm not saying your kid has to be an athlete forever...

January 25, 20268 min read

Y'all, I need to talk about something that I'm seeing more and more of—and it's honestly breaking my heart a little bit. Parents are letting their kids quit sports left and right, and then we wonder why we're raising a generation that gives up when things get hard. Let me be clear about something from the jump: . That's not what this is about. But there's a difference between strategically transitioning away from a sport and just quitting because it's hard or because your kid got frustrated.


The "Secret Level of Crazy" You've Unlocked

You know that moment when your kid comes to you and says they want to quit their sport? And your immediate response is to say yes because you want them to be happy? Yeah, you've just unlocked what I call the "secret level of crazy. "Here's why: the moment you teach your kid that they can just quit when things get uncomfortable, you've set them up for a lifetime of quitting. In school, in relationships, in careers, in life—if their learned pattern is "when this gets hard, I can just stop," you've created a problem.


running up a sand dune

Not Everyone is Cut Out for Athletics

Let me start with this truth: not every kid should be an athlete. Some kids aren't built for the rigor of sports. Some kids don't have the mental toughness. Some kids don't have the passion. And that's okay. That's real. But here's what I see happening: kids are quitting because it's hard, because they're not getting played as much as they want, because a coach said something that hurt their feelings, because they lost a game. And parents are enabling it. The difference is crucial.

Legitimate Reasons to Quit a Sport:

  • Someone is physically draining your child in a harmful way

  • Someone is mentally or emotionally abusing your child

  • The environment is toxic and damaging

  • Your child genuinely doesn't want to be there and hasn't from the start

  • Your child's mental health is suffering

NOT Good Reasons to Quit a Sport:

  • It's hard

  • You're not getting the playing time you want

  • You had a bad game

  • The coach said something tough (that's called coaching)

  • You're tired (everyone's tired)

  • Another sport looks more fun

  • You're not the best player on the team


The Lesson That Actually Matters

What your kids learn when they push through the hard times in athletics is invaluable. They learn: Commitment. You said you were going to do this. You finish what you start. You don't just bail when it gets uncomfortable. Resilience. You got knocked down. You struggled. You had bad games. You kept showing up anyway. That's mental toughness. That's what separates people who succeed from people who don't. Discipline. Athletics teaches discipline in a way nothing else can. You show up at 6 AM for practice whether you feel like it or not. You do the conditioning. You follow the program. You are part of something bigger than yourself. Responsibility to Others. Your teammates depend on you. Your coaches depend on you. You have a commitment to people, not just to yourself. That's a massive life lesson. How to Handle Disappointment. Not every game is a win. You're not always going to get what you want. You have to learn to accept disappointment and keep moving forward anyway. That's real life.


football coach and young player

The "Finish the Season" Rule

Here's what I believe in: your kid finishes the season. Period. Unless there's genuine harm happening—and I mean real, documented harm—your child finishes the commitment they made. They made a commitment to a team, to a coach, to their teammates. And in our house, we don't break commitments because things got hard. One of my favorite comments on this video came from someone who shared: "My kids know they have to finish a season before they can change sport, team, school. The team depends on them and we're not quitters." That's the rule. Finish the season. Then, if they want to do something different next year, we can talk about that. But mid-season quitting? That teaches the worst lesson possible.


What You're Teaching Your Kid When You Let Them Quit

When your kid wants to quit and you immediately agree to it, here's what they learn:

  • When things get hard, I can just stop

  • My comfort matters more than my commitments

  • I don't have to follow through on what I promise

  • Other people's needs (my teammates) don't matter if I'm not feeling it

  • Quitting is an acceptable response to difficulty

Now contrast that with what they learn when they push through:

  • I'm stronger than I thought

  • I can handle hard things

  • Commitment means something

  • Other people are counting on me

  • Quitting is not an option; persistence is

Which version of your kid would you rather raise?


The Hard Conversations You Need to Have

If your kid genuinely wants to quit, you need to have a real conversation with them. Not to let them quit, but to understand what's actually going on .Ask them:

  • What's making you want to quit?

  • Is it the physical rigor? (That's temporary)

  • Is it the coach? (What specifically did they do?)

  • Is it the team? (Are you being mistreated?)

  • Is it just hard? (Yeah, that's kind of the point)

  • Are you embarrassed about your performance? (Most athletes are at some point)

Be the parent who says: "I hear you. This is hard. And you're going to finish this season. In the offseason, we'll talk about what's next. But right now, you're in it, and we finish what we start."


The Rigor of Being an Athlete

Here's something people don't talk about enough: being an athlete builds character. The early morning practices. The conditioning. The games you lose. The plays you mess up. The coaches who push you. The teammates who count on you. All of it is forging who you're going to become. Your kid isn't going to appreciate it at 14. They might not appreciate it at 18. But at 25, when they're facing challenges in their career or their relationships and they push through instead of quitting, they'll remember.

"I did hard things in sports. I can do hard things here too."

That's the gift you're giving them.


The Exception: When Quitting IS the Right Call

I want to be fair here. There ARE times when pulling your kid out of a sport is the right move: Physical Safety: If there's a coaching technique that's causing injury, if the program is reckless with player safety, if there's physical abuse—pull them immediately. Mental Health Crisis: If your child's mental health is genuinely declining, if they're having panic attacks before games, if there's a serious psychological impact—get them help and potentially out of the situation. Documented Abuse: If there's emotional abuse, bullying by coaches or teammates that's creating a harmful environment, psychological manipulation—that's different. Protect your kid. Wrong Fit from the Start: Some kids genuinely are not meant for organized sports. If you've tried and your kid has never wanted to be there, that's different from "wants to quit when it gets hard. "But the casual, "I don't feel like it anymore," quit? That's not acceptable in my house.


What I'm Really Teaching My Kids

When I insist my kids finish what they started in athletics, I'm not doing it to be harsh. I'm doing it because I love them. I'm preparing them for a world that's not going to let them quit just because things get hard. Employers aren't going to say, "Oh, your job's too hard? Just quit!" Life's not going to say, "You're struggling? Just give up!" Relationships don't work that way either. Athletics is the training ground. It's where they learn these lessons in a structured, healthy environment before they need these skills to actually survive in the real world.


coaches talking to young players

The Bottom Line

Quitters never win. That's not just a cute phrase. It's a fundamental truth about how success works. Your kid might not love their sport. They might not become an athlete. They might transition to something else next year. That's fine. But the way you handle the "it's hard" moments is teaching them lessons that will either serve them their entire lives or undermine them. So the next time your kid wants to quit, don't immediately say yes. Say instead: "You finish this season. And then we'll talk about what's next." That's how you raise a kid who doesn't quit. And the world needs more people like that.


Closing

I'm MamaHen, and I'm raising kids who finish what they start. 💕


Key Takeaways

  1. Finishing a season matters. Teach your kids to complete their commitments

  2. Hardship builds character. The struggles in athletics translate to life success

  3. Know the difference. Between quitting because it's hard vs. quitting because of genuine harm

  4. Be the example. Your kids learn commitment from watching you model it

  5. Real love sometimes means pushing. Letting them always get what they want isn't what's best for them


Questions to Ask Your Quitter

  • What specifically about this sport is making you want to quit?

  • If I told you that you have to finish this season, how would that feel?

  • What would you want your teammate to do if they were struggling the way you are?

  • How would you feel about yourself if you quit vs. if you push through?

Nikki Trotter Henry, known as MamaHen, is an athletic recruitment expert, mentor, and advocate for student-athletes and their families. With over three decades of experience in the athletic world—including 30+ years as a coach's wife, 15 years as an AAU mom, and 3 years as an NFL mom—Nikki brings unparalleled real-world insight to the college recruitment landscape.
As a seasoned professional in athletic recruitment strategy, Nikki provides comprehensive guidance on scholarships, recruitment navigation, and athletic development. Her expertise is rooted in firsthand experience with the triumphs, sacrifices, and faith-testing moments that define the athletic family journey.
Through MamaHen, Nikki empowers families to confidently navigate the complex world of college athletics, offering proven strategies and mentorship that transform the recruitment process. Her mission is to ensure that student-athletes and their families are equipped with the knowledge and support needed to succeed both on and off the field.
Connect with MamaHen:
For additional resources and insights, visit www.mamahen.org and follow Nikki on TikTok @nikkitrotterhenry for daily tips and expert advice on athletic recruitment.
Join the Community:

MamaHen Student Community – Connect with fellow student-athletes navigating the recruitment journey
MamaHen Parent Community – Join parents supporting their athletes through college recruitment

Nicole T. Henry

Nikki Trotter Henry, known as MamaHen, is an athletic recruitment expert, mentor, and advocate for student-athletes and their families. With over three decades of experience in the athletic world—including 30+ years as a coach's wife, 15 years as an AAU mom, and 3 years as an NFL mom—Nikki brings unparalleled real-world insight to the college recruitment landscape. As a seasoned professional in athletic recruitment strategy, Nikki provides comprehensive guidance on scholarships, recruitment navigation, and athletic development. Her expertise is rooted in firsthand experience with the triumphs, sacrifices, and faith-testing moments that define the athletic family journey. Through MamaHen, Nikki empowers families to confidently navigate the complex world of college athletics, offering proven strategies and mentorship that transform the recruitment process. Her mission is to ensure that student-athletes and their families are equipped with the knowledge and support needed to succeed both on and off the field. Connect with MamaHen: For additional resources and insights, visit www.mamahen.org and follow Nikki on TikTok @nikkitrotterhenry for daily tips and expert advice on athletic recruitment. Join the Community: MamaHen Student Community – Connect with fellow student-athletes navigating the recruitment journey MamaHen Parent Community – Join parents supporting their athletes through college recruitment

LinkedIn logo icon
Back to Blog